For another great Pumpkin recipe, check out my latest Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookies!! To die for!!
************************************
I about cried when he showed up at home that night with a big ol' piece he said he saved just for me. Good, good hubby!

Let me lay it out for you. We are talking about a buttery pecan crust, topped with a sweet cream cheese layer, the pumpkin pie pudding layer, and it's finished off with a layer of cool whip....and I gave it a sprinkle of nutmeg just for fun.

Pumpkin Lust Cake
from Debbie Mortensen
1 stick butter, melted
1 cup flour
1 cup chopped pecans
2 tbs sugar
1 (8oz) package of cream chees, soft
1 cup powdered sugar
2 (8 oz) containers cool whip (or one 16 ozz container)
2 small packages (3.4oz) of Jello Instant Pumpkin Spice Pudding
3 cup cold milk
Nutmeg for sprinkling
For the crust:
1. Combine butter, flour, chopped pecans and sugar and press into a 9 x 13 in baking dish. Bake at 375 for 10-15 minutes. Let cool completely.
For the Cream Cheese Layer:
1. Beat cream cheese, powdered sugar, and 1 1/2 cups cool whip until smooth. Spread over crust.
For the Pumpkin Layer:
1. Mix pudding mixes with cold milk, whisking for several minutes. Set it in the fridge for 5-10 minutes to let it thicken. Spread over the cream cheese layer. Top with remaining container of cool whip. Sprinkle with nutmeg.
Cut into squares and serve. Keep refrigerated.













Wow. I need this in my liiife! Lust cake? Pumpkin? I'm in!
ReplyDeleteWow, this looks incredibly delicious! Looks like I'll be running to the store to grab some pudding :)
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to try this!! Thanks for sharing : )
ReplyDeleteWow, that looks amazing! You know how much I love pumpkin. Bookmarking this one!
ReplyDeleteIn high school my friend's mom used to make something called 'Better Than Sex Cake' and it sounds like this is very similar but with the addition of pumpkin! I bet this is delicious!
ReplyDeleteMade this last year for Thanksgiving and it was a big hit! This has been the "go-to" dessert at our house for years, made with every flavor of pudding imaginable with butterscotch or pumpkin being the favorites.
ReplyDeleteI am totally making this! I love love love the crust. YUM! :)
ReplyDeleteWow!!! I am not a pumpkin pie person at all and my family thinks I am nuts, but I think that I would definitely love this. I am making this for Thanksgiving because I am sure that they will love love love it!
ReplyDeleteI make this every year for Thanksgiving but with either chocolate or butterscotch pudding. Pumpkin is going in it this year! Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteTotal L.U.S.T going on here right now - I want that slice!
ReplyDeleteWe always make this on holidays but with lemon!! Everyone's favorite will have to try it this way!
ReplyDeleteThis is just like the georgie porgie (that's what we call it in my family) that I make during the summer! Pumpkin pudding would be a cool substitution.
ReplyDeleteI have a dessert that is kinda like this that is made with graham crackers. Well if you use the pumpking pudding and then can find the gingerbread graham crackers to layer in it. It is the greatest thing. Everyone loves it even those that dont like pumpking.
ReplyDeleteI have used this recipe for years with chocolate and lemon pudding mixes. I always use a graham cracker crust and I can tell you, it's a hit every time. I can't wait to try the pumpkin version. I'm having a hard time finding the pudding though.
ReplyDelete@ Lanette-- I found mine at Wal-Mart! Hopefully you can find it. I've also heard butterscotch is really good too!!
ReplyDeleteThis is my favorite dessert when I make it with pistachio pudding, but I LOVE pumpkin stuff so I will be trying this as soon as I can find some pumpkin spice pudding! Thanks for the tip.
ReplyDeleteOur family doesn't care for pecans so how do you think it would taste with a pie crust instead? Also, the pudding was a little too spicy for my taste but I love the pumpkin flavor- any suggestions other than mixing some cool whip in?
ReplyDelete@Anonymous-
ReplyDeleteI think it would be great in a pie crust! I was thinking about mixing one box of pumpkin spice pudding with a box of vanilla pudding next time I make it! That might tone down the pumpkin flavor for ya!!
Good luck!
Have you read the ingredients in the pumpkin pie pudding mix? There is not only no pumpkin, there are a whole lot of seriously bad ingredients:
ReplyDeleteSUGAR, MODIFIED CORNSTARCH, CONTAINS LESS THAN 2% OF NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, CINNAMON, GINGER, SALT, DISODIUM PHOSPHATE AND TETRASODIUM PYROPHOSPHATE (FOR THICKENING), MONO- AND DIGLYCERIDES (PREVENT FOAMING), YELLOW 5, YELLOW 6, CARAMEL COLOR, ARTIFICIAL COLOR, BHA (PRESERVATIVE).
...and don't let me get started on Cool Whip!!! At least they actually put some milk and cream in it now, but the hyrogenated oil and high-fructose corn syrup are deadly!
ReplyDelete@ Jane- Thanks for the information. I've thought about using real pumpkin filling or making a real pumpkin cheese-cake type filling that would also be good. And you can always make your own whipping cream. I definitely never claimed this was a healthy dessert....I guess that's why it's a "yearly" Thanksgiving indulgence!
ReplyDeleteMy step-dad makes the chocolate version of this (sex in a pan) and it is delish! I can't wait to surprise him with this pumpkin version on Thanksgiving this year! THANKS!!
ReplyDeleteWe made a similar pudding cake, but did one layer of chocolate pudding and then one layer of butterscotch pudding as well. I also make my own whipped cream instead of cool whip. So much richer and less artificial tasting. I then top it with more pecans or chocolate sprinkles or dust it with cocoa powder. Divine!
ReplyDeleteI made this with vanilla pudding and added pumpkin pie spice. Here in Maui it is hard to find the seasonal pudding. It worked out great!
ReplyDeleteOne of my favorite pumpkin desserts. I linked back to your site.
Mahalo for sharing!
@Kristen--I plan on making it with homemade whipping cream for Thanksgiving!! So much better!!
ReplyDelete@ Star-- I'm so glad it worked and tasted great with the pumpkin pie spice!!
I can't wait to try this! FYI...whenever I see 'difficult to find' I immediately jump on the web. Today, I found this jello at netgrocer.com...so there's hope if you cannot find it locally. :)
ReplyDeleteAnd now there has been a run on Pumpkin Spice Pudding mix so it is no longer available in ANY stores! LOL! Yum - looks delish. (And yes, I would probably make my own version of the ingredients since I try to avoid chemicals as much as possible!)
ReplyDeleteI am making this now, but using a cup of pumpkin puree in place of one of the cups of milk. I think that it needs some real pumpkin :)
ReplyDeleteKristy,
ReplyDeleteI can't find the pudding in the stores around me. Any suggestions for a substitute?
I found the pudding in a center aisle with other holiday baking items at my Wal-Mart. I'm about to make this now and take it to a get together with friends tonight.
ReplyDeleteI make this every year, with choc pudding, & just leave the nuts out
ReplyDelete@anonymous,
ReplyDeleteIf you can't find the pumpkin pudding you could add some real pumpkin and/or pumpkin pie spice to a box of vanilla pudding! A reader said she d this and it turned out great!! Good luck!!
I"m on low carb and trying to figure out how I can make something similar to this. SF pudding with my own spice in it, whipped cream instead of Cool Whip, An almond and pecan flour crust,,,,the powdered sugar is my problem,,,can't sub that....
ReplyDeleteI've been making this recipe( and have shared the recipe almost each time I've taken it to a social ) since about 1985. We call it Lemon Lush with lemon pudding, with chocolate pudding its called Chocolate Surprise, and with butterscotch pudding its Butterscotch Spectacular. This Pumpkin Lust is a new flavor treat! The original recipe was sweet enough not using sugar in the crust and only 1/2 cup of powd sugar in the cream cheese layer.I hope our grocer has this Pumpkin Spice pudding.Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteMy husband's family makes a version of this with chocolate pudding instead of pumpkin, and it's heavenly. MIL also makes it with a berries and glaze layer in place of the pudding, and that's really good, too. I can't wait to try this!
ReplyDeleteyou could also use a can of condensed milk boil it in water until it turns into caramel make sure you put a couple of small holes in the can before you boil it,it will tastes like O'Charleys Caramel pie.
ReplyDeleteI made this for our early Thanksgiving dinner this year and took the leftovers (of which there were LOTS) into my office. It was a HUGE hit with all my co-workers. Next year I'm thinking about putting some chocolate shavings on top. Or maybe doubling the cookie layer. Regardless - it was DELISH!
ReplyDeleteI just finished making this! It's in the fridge now, and I can't wait for my husband to get home so that we can cut into it! It was so easy to make and looks fantastic! Thanks so much for sharing the recipe!
ReplyDeleteI'm so excited about making this to take to Thanksgiving dinner at friends'! I looked all over town and couldn't find the pudding, so in desperation I bought vanilla pudding and a can of pumpkin. Already had pumpkin pie spice. I was relieved to come home and read that this substitution works well. Thanks for the recipe and all the helpful comments! Happy Thanksgiving, y'all!
ReplyDeleteThe beauty of an indulgent dessert is that it's something you enjoy occasionally. If I wanted to bake a pumpkin something-or-other from scratch I wouldn't have given this recipe a second look. But you know what? This is great as is. It's kind of like eating at McDonalds...you know it's bad for you but once or twice a year it just hits the spot. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteSo want to make this for Thanksgiving, but I can not locate the pudding. I've made it numerous times with the chocolate pudding, but...
ReplyDeleteSounds fabulous! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI picked up some gingerbread and peppermint jello pudding mixes this year. I bet they would be good too!
ReplyDeleteI made this last night and WOW it is yummy! I think next time if I have more time I will make my own pumpkin filling. I loved it still though!!!
ReplyDeleteI went to Staters and Vons before finally finding the Pumpkin Spice instant pudding at my Ralphs...whew, 3rd times a charm! Like a madwoman, I grabbed 8 boxes to save me the trouble next time 'round (exp July 2013!). I don't eve know if I like this recipe yet lol, but it looks so promising and better be since I can make it 4 x's ; ) 2 more days before I get to gobble it up...CAN'T WAIT!!! Thanks for sharing this simple, yummy-looking recipe!
ReplyDeleteI made this over the weekend to rave reviews! I couldn't find pumpkin pudding either, and subbed gingerbread pudding. My guests and I thought it was wonderful. I love the idea of using a gingerbread crust with this, going to try that next time!
ReplyDeleteI couldn't find pumpkin pudding, so I used 1 cup canned pumpkin mixed with 1 box instant vanilla pudding, 2/3 cup milk, cinnamon and nutmeg.
ReplyDeleteis it 2 pkts equalling 3.4 oz. or 2 pkgs 3.4 oz. each?
ReplyDeleteJust finished making this and looking forward to trying it tomorrow. I looked at all the local stores with no luck on the pumpkin pudding until my mother in law found just one box at Walmart. I mixed one pumpkin and one vanilla to cover the two boxes needed.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the twist on this recipe - I have made the chocolate one and it was a family favorite.
I substituted almonds in place of the pecans because my kids have an allergy to pecans. This is so delicious and I am not a pumpkin person at all! I would highly recommend this and thanks for the advice of the other posters I will try it with chocolate or butterscotch pudding when I can't find pumpkin! THANK YOU for sharing!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteI made this tonight and had to sneak a piece before taking it to the family gathering tomorrow. A-MAZING.
ReplyDeleteI just made this and thought it was pretty good. Next time I'd double the crust (best part!) and use less cool whip. Canned pumpkin mixed with vanilla pudding would be good too instead of the pumpkin pudding. A lot of wiggle room here but great, easy recipe!
ReplyDeleteA nice option for the crust could be 6 tablespoons butter & 40 crushed gingersnap cookies pressed into pan, cook for 20 minutes @ 350. I use this crust for cheesecake I make & it is delish.
ReplyDeleteKaren
Making this for thanksgiving right now! Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI've made this 2 times in the last week for family functions and everyone has loved it! I haven't been able to find the pumpkin spice pudding so I used vanilla pudding, 1.5 cups of milk and a cup of pumpkin puree and a teaspoon or so of pumpkin pie spice! It is delicious!!
ReplyDeleteI made this for our Thanksgiving get together and it was very well received.
ReplyDeleteI left the sugar out of the crust and used regular granulated sugar for the cream cheese layer (because I make a similar thing with chocolate, vanilla, lemon, and banana pudding and I made this one much the same way).
My husband said this was the best dessert he has had. I can not eat gluten so I substituted the crumbs for gluten free oats and we loved it! Thanks for the recipe
ReplyDeleteJust found your blog through Pinterest. I love the aesthetic! Thanks for this great recipe, I featured it on the "friday finds" post I did today.
ReplyDeletehttp://curtnlinds.blogspot.com/2011/11/friday-finds-pumpkin-lust-cake.html
Sorry for posting as Anonymous, I got to this page from Pinterest,and don't have any of the listed accounts!!
ReplyDeleteYUM!! thank you for taking the time to post this delicious recipe and "pooh pooh" to Jane for her negative remarks on pudding/cool whip! .... What if you eat 100% healthy foods 100% of the time and you end up getting hit by a bus?? LIVE A LITTLE!!! My kids know by heart to eat "everything in moderation" and to enjoy life! We get a similar treat from my MIL (once a year only!!) she calls "Melt in your mouth" and has the chocolate/vanilla mix in the middle. OMG - delish!!!
I made this recipe and wrote about it here. We had it as our Thanksgiving dessert.
ReplyDeleteI plan on making it again and again.
Thank you so much for sharing this delicious recipe.
This is the best recipe EVER for a pumpkin dessert of ANY kind! I LOVE IT! But the pumpkin pudding is so very hard to find. I wanted to make more for Christmas but no pumpkin pudding. Anyone know how to make a substitute for the recipe out of real pumpkin, pumpkin pie mix, etc? There has to be a way! I think I am going to try it with some vanilla pudding mix and adding a little pumpkin pie mix to flavor it. I feel like an addict -- JUST HAVE TO HAVE MORE PUMPKIN LUST CAKE!!! PLC NOW! I have even ordered some of the pumpkin spice pudding online at a ridiculous $3 a box price! Hopefully it will come in before Christmas! I'll stock up next Thanksgiving!
ReplyDeleteMy son in law made this for Thanksgiving and instead of pumpkin pudding used vanilla pudding and pumpkin pie spice. This way you can make it as spicy as you want. It was a huge hit and we all really loved it. One of us will be making it for Christmas.
ReplyDeletethis looks great even with all the stuff that is bad for you. I plan to use vanilla pudding and pumpkin pie and pumpkin pie spice because that is what I have one hand.
ReplyDeleteI substituted pumpkin pie pudding with 2 sm. pkgs of vanilla pudding mixed with one can of pumpkin pie filling and a tsp of pumpkin pie spice. It makes too much (unless you like a little extra) so I ended up not using about a cup of it.
ReplyDeleteAlso, to switch it up a bit, the next time I made it I used coconut pudding and then drizzled caramel on top, and then the cool whip. SUCH A HIT! Delicious :) I plan on making a chocolate mint one soon too!
Our family makes this all the time minus the cream cheese layer and using pistachio pudding instead of the pumpkin. Doesn't last long. I am looking forward to trying this recipe. Sounds amazing!! :)
ReplyDeleteI tried your recipe...since I couldn't find pumpkin pudding and I don't really care for instant I changed it up a bit. I used cooked vanilla pudding and added some allspice to it, then after it chilled I added a can of packed pumpkin...it turned out amazing....
ReplyDeleteI've been making this for years and years but my version has always been with Pistachio pudding! And I could eat a ton of it!!! I've seen it with chocolate and lemon before and it was really good, but Pistachio always being my favorite and the crust reminds me of pecan sandies! I'll certainly have to give the pumpkin a try....sounds wonderful!
ReplyDeleteI've enjoyed this dessert for years and years but my version has always been with Pistachio pudding! Love the crust...reminds me of pecan sandies! I've also had it with chocolate and lemon, both deliciopus, but I've always remained a faithful lover of the Pistachio.....now I'll have to try the pumpkin! Sounds heavenly!
ReplyDeleteRepinned onto my pumpkin board so in 6 mos when I need my go-to thanksgiving (easy!) dessert, I will have this idea waiting! My mom makes a lemon lust that is so good, gotta try yours.
ReplyDeleteSo impressed that your husband saved and brought you home a piece. What a thoughtful man. Does he have a brother ;)
ReplyDelete